The Likely Increase in Commercial Real Estate Mortgage Rates: Understanding SOFR and Credit Spreads

Commercial real estate (CRE) mortgage rates are influenced by a combination of benchmark interest rates and lender-specific pricing considerations. Since the transition away from LIBOR, the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) has become the primary benchmark for floating rate commercial loans in the United States. As a result, the all-in borrowing cost for most commercial mortgages is determined by adding a negotiated credit spread to the prevailing SOFR.

Looking ahead, commercial real estate borrowers are likely to experience higher mortgage rates if either SOFR increases, lender spreads widen, or both occur simultaneously. Understanding these two components is essential for evaluating future financing costs and investment returns.

The interest rate on a floating-rate commercial mortgage can be expressed using a straightforward formula:

Mortgage Rate = SOFR + Credit Spread

SOFR represents the benchmark risk-free borrowing rate based on transactions in the overnight Treasury repurchase (repo) market. Because it reflects the cost of borrowing cash collateralized by U.S. Treasury securities, SOFR is considered a highly liquid and transparent benchmark. Unlike LIBOR, SOFR does not contain a bank credit risk premium. Consequently, lenders establish their desired return by adding a spread that compensates them for credit risk, liquidity risk, operating costs, capital requirements, and expected profitability.

The first driver of higher commercial mortgage rates is the direction of SOFR itself. SOFR closely follows the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy. When inflation remains above the Federal Reserve’s target or economic conditions require tighter financial conditions, the Federal Reserve may maintain higher short-term interest rates for an extended period. Because SOFR moves almost in lockstep with the federal funds rate, any continuation of restrictive monetary policy will keep SOFR elevated. Even if the Federal Reserve begins reducing rates, policymakers have repeatedly indicated that future easing is likely to occur gradually rather than rapidly, suggesting that SOFR may remain above its long-term average for some time.

However, benchmark rates alone do not explain current borrowing costs in commercial real estate. The second component, the spread above SOFR, has become increasingly important. During periods of economic uncertainty, lenders generally require greater compensation for assuming credit risk. Commercial real estate currently faces several challenges that justify wider spreads from a lender’s perspective. Office properties continue to experience elevated vacancy rates due to hybrid work arrangements and changing tenant demand. Retail properties must adapt to evolving consumer behavior and continued competition from e-commerce. Multifamily assets face rising operating expenses, insurance costs, and regulatory pressures in certain markets. Industrial and logistics facilities remain relatively strong, but even these sectors are not immune to higher financing costs and slowing economic growth.

Together, these conditions increase uncertainty regarding future property income and collateral values. As property values become more difficult to predict, lenders typically respond by increasing the spread they charge over SOFR. Wider spreads compensate for higher probabilities of default, declining collateral values, refinancing risk, and potential losses during economic downturns. For example, a commercial mortgage that may have been priced at SOFR plus 200 basis points during a highly competitive lending environment could instead be priced at SOFR plus 275 or even 350 basis points if market conditions deteriorate or lender risk tolerance declines.

Bank regulation also contributes to wider spreads. Financial institutions have faced increased regulatory scrutiny regarding commercial real estate exposure, particularly office lending. Regulators have encouraged banks to strengthen capital positions and carefully manage concentration risk within their CRE portfolios. Higher capital requirements effectively increase the cost of lending, and lenders often pass these additional costs on to borrowers through wider credit spreads.

Another important factor is liquidity. Regional banking stress and reduced lending activity have limited the availability of commercial real estate financing. When fewer lenders actively compete for new loans, borrowers generally have less negotiating leverage. Reduced competition allows remaining lenders to maintain higher spreads while still attracting qualified borrowers. Debt funds, insurance companies, and private credit providers have filled part of this financing gap, but these alternative lenders often target higher returns than traditional banks, which may also contribute to elevated borrowing costs.

Commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) markets also influence lending spreads. Investors purchasing CMBS bonds demand yields that reflect expected credit losses, market volatility, and economic uncertainty. When CMBS bond spreads widen, loan originators typically increase the spreads charged on newly originated mortgages to preserve profitability. Consequently, capital market conditions can directly affect borrowing costs even if SOFR remains unchanged.

Property-specific characteristics further influence the spread over SOFR. Lenders evaluate loan to-value ratios, debt service coverage ratios, sponsorship quality, tenant diversification, lease rollover schedules, property age, market location, and asset condition. Properties with stable cash flow, strong occupancy, long-term leases, and experienced ownership generally qualify for narrower spreads. Conversely, transitional assets, properties requiring substantial capital improvements, or buildings with significant lease expirations may face considerably higher spreads due to increased perceived risk.

The refinancing environment presents another reason mortgage rates may remain elevated. Many commercial real estate loans originated during periods of exceptionally low interest rates will mature over the next several years. Borrowers refinancing these loans will likely face substantially higher all-in interest costs. Even if SOFR declines modestly, wider lender spreads may offset much of the benefit. This refinancing challenge could reduce property values, increase debt service burdens, and pressure borrowers to contribute additional equity at loan maturity.

From an investment perspective, higher commercial mortgage rates have several important implications. Increased financing costs reduce leveraged returns, lower debt service coverage ratios, and may decrease the amount lenders are willing to finance. Investors may respond by demanding higher capitalization rates to compensate for increased financing expenses and risk. Higher cap rates generally correspond to lower property valuations, particularly for assets with limited rental growth potential.

Borrowers can partially mitigate these risks through several strategies. Interest rate caps can protect against future increases in SOFR for floating-rate loans. Fixed-rate financing may provide certainty despite initially higher coupon rates. Maintaining conservative leverage, strengthening property cash flow, extending lease terms, and preserving adequate liquidity can improve credit quality and potentially reduce the spread lenders require. Building strong relationships with multiple lending sources may also enhance negotiating leverage during refinancing.

In conclusion, the outlook for commercial real estate mortgage rates depends on both the future path of SOFR and the credit spread lenders charge above the benchmark. While SOFR reflects Federal Reserve monetary policy and broader economic conditions, the spread captures lender perceptions of credit risk, market liquidity, regulatory requirements, and property-specific factors. Given ongoing uncertainty in commercial real estate markets, tighter lending standards, refinancing pressures, and constrained credit availability, borrowers should anticipate that all-in mortgage rates may remain elevated even if benchmark interest rates begin to decline. Successful borrowers will increasingly focus not only on forecasting SOFR but also on managing the factors that influence credit spreads, as both components together determine the true cost of commercial real estate financing.